April 30, 2025 Newsletter

CT header image.jpg

Why You Keep Having the Same Argument

Ever feel like you and your partner are stuck in a loop? You know the one—where the same argument seems to pop up over and over again, no matter what the trigger is. Maybe it starts with a forgotten errand or a sarcastic comment, but somehow you always end up in the same emotional place: misunderstood, frustrated, and disconnected.

You're not alone. In fact, most couples don’t have dozens of unique arguments—they have one or two recurring conflicts that keep resurfacing in different forms.

It’s Not About the Dishes

When partners get into repeated arguments, it’s usually not about surface-level issues. It’s about the deeper emotional needs that are going unmet. For example:

  • “You never help around the house” may really mean “I need to feel supported.”

  • “You’re always on your phone” might actually be “I miss our connection.”

  • “Why didn’t you text me back?” could be “I need reassurance that I matter to you.”

These hidden needs—feeling heard, valued, secure, or emotionally close—drive the cycle.

What Keeps the Cycle Going?

When these emotional needs aren’t acknowledged or expressed clearly, both partners can fall into reactive patterns:

  • One partner pushes for connection (criticizes, nags, demands).

  • The other partner withdraws or defends (shuts down, avoids, deflects).

This creates what’s known in couples therapy as a pursue-withdraw dynamic, and it often leads to both people feeling more alone, even though they’re trying (in their own way) to feel close.

Breaking the Pattern Together

Here’s how to begin shifting the cycle:

  1. Pause the Pattern: When you notice you're in that familiar argument, pause. Take a breath. Name it: “I think we’re doing that thing again.”

  2. Get Curious About the Need: Ask yourself: What do I really need right now? What might my partner be needing?

  3. Use Clear Language: Replace blame with vulnerability. Try: “When X happens, I feel Y, because I need Z.”

  4. Reconnect Intentionally: Choose a time when you’re both calm to talk about how to approach these moments differently.

Repair isn’t about never arguing—it’s about noticing the pattern and working together to understand it.

You’re Not Broken—You’re Learning

Repeated arguments don’t mean your relationship is doomed. They’re opportunities to grow if you’re both willing to look beneath the surface. Learning how to express needs and respond to your partner’s with empathy can completely transform how you communicate.

The goal isn’t to eliminate conflict but to create space for emotional repair, deeper understanding, and trust that can withstand the tough moments.

✨ A thriving relationship isn’t one without arguments—it’s one where both people feel safe enough to work through them together.